A PARK WITHIN PHOENIX PARK
In the heart of the People’s Flower Garden, a solitary plinth stands as a silent witness to a bygone era. This classically-styled pedestal once supported a bronze statue of George William Frederick Howard, the 7th Earl of Carlisle. Erected around 1870, the statue was the work of renowned Irish sculptor, John Henry Foley, whose other notable works include the statue of Prince Albert at the Albert Memorial in London and the Daniel O’Connell Monument in Dublin.
The Earl of Carlisle was a prominent figure in 19th-century Irish politics, serving as Chief Secretary and twice as Lord Lieutenant of Ireland. He played a key role in the creation of the People’s Garden, envisioning it as a place for the “recreation and instruction of the poor of Dublin”. In a time when monuments in Irish municipal parks were rare, the Carlisle Monument held a unique position as the sole statue in the People’s Garden.
However, the monument’s story took a dramatic turn in 1956 when a bomb dislodged the bronze statue from its pedestal. The statue was subsequently relocated to Castle Howard in Yorkshire, England, the Earl’s ancestral home. The plinth, however, remained in Dublin, a poignant reminder of the Earl’s legacy and a testament to the changing tides of history.
Today, the plinth stands as a central focus in a grassy area at the southwest edge of the gardens near Chesterfield Avenue. Its inscriptions provide a glimpse into the life of the Earl of Carlisle:
North face: “Erected by public subscription 1870”
South face: “George Wm. Frederick, seventh Earl of Carlisle, K.G / Chief Secretary for Ireland, 1835 to 1841 / Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, 1855-1858 and 1859 to 1864 / Born 1802. Died 1864.”
Surrounded by low-level planting, the plinth serves as a quiet place for reflection, inviting visitors to contemplate the complexities of history and the enduring power of public spaces.