Uncategorized

---

---

Archer’s Garage, located at the corner of Fenian Street and Sandwith Street Upper in Dublin, has a rich and somewhat controversial history.  

Original Building (1946)

The original Archer’s Garage was constructed in 1946. It was designed by Billy Baird of Kaye Parry Ross Hendy architects for Richard Archer, the first agent for Ford motorcars in Ireland. This building was considered groundbreaking for its time, as it was the first in Ireland to be built with reinforced concrete and fitted with fluorescent lighting.  

The design was a striking example of Art Deco architecture, featuring a distinctive curved corner tower with a flagpole and projecting fins for signage. This tower served as a visual anchor for the building, emphasising its presence at the intersection of two streets. The garage’s design also incorporated functional elements, such as an open ground-level forecourt that allowed for easy access of vehicles.  

Illegal Demolition and Reconstruction (1999-2004)

In 1999, the building, despite being a listed structure, was illegally demolished over a June bank holiday weekend by property developer Noel O’Callaghan. This act sparked public outrage and led to legal action by Dublin City Council.  

The developer was ultimately forced to reconstruct the building as a condition of the planning permission for a new office and residential development on the site. The reconstruction was completed in 2004.  

Controversy Surrounding the Reconstruction

While the reconstruction aimed to replicate the original structure, it has been criticised for being a poor imitation. Many argue that the replacement lacks the fine details and craftsmanship of the original Art Deco building. Some of the specific criticisms include:

Loss of architectural detail: The new building is seen as a simplified version of the original, lacking the nuanced design elements and intricate details that defined the Art Deco style.
Materials and construction quality: Concerns have been raised about the quality of materials used in the reconstruction and whether they accurately reflect the original construction.
Overall aesthetic impact: Many feel that the replacement building fails to capture the spirit and elegance of the original, resulting in a diminished visual impact.
The controversy surrounding Archer’s Garage highlights the challenges of reconstructing historic buildings. While the replacement structure may be a faithful replica in terms of its overall form, it arguably falls short in replicating the intangible qualities that made the original building so special.

Significance and Context

The story of Archer’s Garage is significant for several reasons:

Architectural heritage: It underscores the importance of preserving architectural heritage, particularly in a city like Dublin where relatively few Art Deco buildings remain intact.
Planning and development: The case led to changes in Irish planning law, with the introduction of stricter penalties for illegal demolition of protected structures.  
Public awareness: It raised public awareness about the value of architectural heritage and the need for responsible development practices.
Archer’s Garage serves as a reminder of the ongoing tension between preservation and development, and the challenges of balancing these competing interests in a rapidly changing urban environment.

If you’d like to delve deeper into this topic, I recommend exploring the following resources:

Archiseek: This website provides detailed information about Irish architecture, including a page dedicated to Archer’s Garage.
Come Here To Me: This blog features an article that discusses the history of Archer’s Garage and the controversy surrounding its demolition and reconstruction.
Dublin City Council website: You can find information about planning regulations and listed buildings in Dublin on the official website.

Info Box

Archer’s Garage, located at the corner of Fenian Street and Sandwith Street Upper in Dublin, has a rich and somewhat controversial history.  
Original Building (1946)
The original Archer’s Garage was constructed in 1946. It was designed by Billy Baird of Kaye Parry Ross Hendy architects for Richard Archer, the first agent for Ford motorcars in Ireland. This building was considered groundbreaking for its time, as it was the first in Ireland to be built with reinforced concrete and fitted with fluorescent lighting.  
The design was a striking example of Art Deco architecture, featuring a distinctive curved corner tower with a flagpole and projecting fins for signage. This tower served as a visual anchor for the building, emphasising its presence at the intersection of two streets. The garage’s design also incorporated functional elements, such as an open ground-level forecourt that allowed for easy access of vehicles.  
Illegal Demolition and Reconstruction (1999-2004)
In 1999, the building, despite being a listed structure, was illegally demolished over a June bank holiday weekend by property developer Noel O’Callaghan. This act sparked public outrage and led to legal action by Dublin City Council.  
The developer was ultimately forced to reconstruct the building as a condition of the planning permission for a new office and residential development on the site. The reconstruction was completed in 2004.  
Controversy Surrounding the Reconstruction
While the reconstruction aimed to replicate the original structure, it has been criticised for being a poor imitation. Many argue that the replacement lacks the fine details and craftsmanship of the original Art Deco building. Some of the specific criticisms include:
Loss of architectural detail: The new building is seen as a simplified version of the original, lacking the nuanced design elements and intricate details that defined the Art Deco style.
Materials and construction quality: Concerns have been raised about the quality of materials used in the reconstruction and whether they accurately reflect the original construction.
Overall aesthetic impact: Many feel that the replacement building fails to capture the spirit and elegance of the original, resulting in a diminished visual impact.
The controversy surrounding Archer’s Garage highlights the challenges of reconstructing historic buildings. While the replacement structure may be a faithful replica in terms of its overall form, it arguably falls short in replicating the intangible qualities that made the original building so special.
Significance and Context
The story of Archer’s Garage is significant for several reasons:
Architectural heritage: It underscores the importance of preserving architectural heritage, particularly in a city like Dublin where relatively few Art Deco buildings remain intact.
Planning and development: The case led to changes in Irish planning law, with the introduction of stricter penalties for illegal demolition of protected structures.  
Public awareness: It raised public awareness about the value of architectural heritage and the need for responsible development practices.
Archer’s Garage serves as a reminder of the ongoing tension between preservation and development, and the challenges of balancing these competing interests in a rapidly changing urban environment.
If you’d like to delve deeper into this topic, I recommend exploring the following resources:
Archiseek: This website provides detailed information about Irish architecture, including a page dedicated to Archer’s Garage.
Come Here To Me: This blog features an article that discusses the history of Archer’s Garage and the controversy surrounding its demolition and reconstruction.
Dublin City Council website: You can find information about planning regulations and listed buildings in Dublin on the official website.